RuneScape talk:Images and media policy

The issue at hand with this criterion is whether images showing how items look when equipped should be allowed to depict equipment other than the piece at question. I think that if an image is supposed to show one item, then it should show that one item and no others. In the case of set images, obviously it is acceptable to have the full set on, but not for those that show individual items. During the debate on the IRC over this, the counter-argument that it would be much more difficult to have animations for each individual item was presented. I don't see why it's necessary to have them animated in this case; the only benefit an animation has over a still image is that slightly more of the item is shown. On the other hand, we either have an inconsistent standard for such images or we allow images that potentially show the items in question an an unclear way. Debating on the IRC has gotten nowhere, so I'd like the community to decide on the merits of these arguments. Skill 03:33, 6 December 2007 (UTC)