RuneScape:Requests for splitting/Ali the Wise 2

Ali the Wise

 * > Previous RfS

This issue has been brought up again in RuneScape:Requests_for_merging/Agrith_Naar. In that RfM, we seem largely in favour of not merging an article that is the same case as Ali the Wise. I still oppose censoring spoilers on the wiki, but in the case of Ali the Wise, I believe we've proved that there's just no accurate way to merge such articles together. Ali the Wise is just a mess. There's no real way to read the article properly.

Thus, I am proposing that Wahisietel be split into his own article, with a section in Ali the Wise mentioning that he reveals himself to be Wahisietel and with a link to that article (I'd really rather we scrap the whole spoiler thing, but whatever). The Wahisietel shouldn't need the spoiler template (it's the whole page).

Our granularity policy states:

I believe that in cases like this, there is a significant difference between the two. How we define significant is left up to consensus and common sense, but if anything is a significant difference, Ali the Wise and Wahisietel are it.

To sum that up, having Ali the Wise and Wahisietel on the same page is just a mess. They should be split not because of the spoiler potential, but rather because it's a mess to read.

Discussion
Support - As nom. 17:52, May 25, 2012 (UTC)