RuneScape:WikiGuilds/Proposals/Stub or not to stub project

Description

I've been skulking around the community portal recently, and I've been checking in on the stubs section. If you havent recently checked there are ALOT of stubs on here. Theres a problem: lots of these "stubs" aren't REALLY stubs.

The thing is, lots of these articles are music articles and articles for useless objects. The articles aren't very long or detailed, but there isn't that much stuff you can say about a music track or a small quest item useless outside a quest. So therefore, this thing shouldn't be a stub, cause it can't be expanded. People seem to just go around and slap that stub thingamagig on any article that is short.

My proposal is to create a project that seeks to remove stub labels from articles that are short, but aren't exactly stubs. I mean, it cant be a stub unless its something that can be expanded that is short. Or at least, thats my interpretation. Is it yours?

[edit]SONSP Project Aims:
If you still aren't convinced of what I'm trying to say then take a lookie at this here article about a key used in a quest:
 * Remove stubs labels from articles that don't really have much else to say about them.
 * Have more explanation and info about what exactly a stub is. (I mean, a new user on the wiki may think its really helpful to put the stub bit on short articles, without much looking to see if there is really anything else to say about said object or music track)

http://runescape.wikia.com/wiki/A_small_key

^ The stub label is at the very bottom of the page, under the key thing. See this article? Thats what I mean! This article is well linked and written. There isn't anything else to say about this little key, and most players just chuck this sort of object out after the quest is over anyway.

If you want to look for some examples yourself, heres the link to the stubs pages:

http://runescape.wikia.com/wiki/Category:Stubs

NOTE: I'm not saying that ALL the articles on the stubs section are like this. Just most of them.

Thanks! Looking forward to some supporters!

R3m3mb3r 23:40, June 10, 2010 (UTC)

[edit]Interested Runescape Wikians (please add your name)
R3m3mb3r 23:43, June 10, 2010 (UTC) HAHHAHA yes I support!