RuneScape:Requests for deletion/Black party hat

Black party hat
I thought this would be covered under the fake image VFD, but apparently it isn't, so here goes. Black party hats have never existed and never will, and so to be allowed would have to come under the RuneScape:Non-existent item policy. However,


 * It doesn't fall under criterion five, because it's not really a black/white item in the real sense. Most players, even newbies, aren't going to assume that because there is a white party hat there must be a black one.
 * My opinion is that it doesn't fall under criterion four either, because the legend isn't widely recognized. I personally have never heard of it before coming here, and a quick Google search shows us as pretty much the only site that talks about this myth.

It would be nice if this discussion were about the merits of this argument rather than the merits of the previous deletions. Skill 06:51, 1 November 2007 (UTC)