- Add tomato to the pizza base which can be bought from Tony's Pizza Bases costing 4 coins.
- Add cheese to the incomplete pizza.
- Cook the uncooked pizza on the nearby range to make a plain pizza.
- Add anchovies to the pizza.
- Raw anchovies can be fished nearby from the Fishing spot on the eastern side of the Bandit Camp and it can be cooked on the range (not actually required for achievement, but it is convenient).
- Give the pizza to Fat Tony.
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.