A popsicle tray is found in the Seal Camp during Some Like it Cold. Players must use soap on the empty tray, making the soaped popsicle tray, to make game pieces for the Battlefish game set.
- When used on Teddy, he says: "When there wasn't enough food in winter, I had to eat ice. I don't want any popsicles." or, after it's filled with soap: "Are you trying to trick me into eating soap?"