I suggested a while back that the luring page should be changed, removing most of the content (especially any lures which can still be used). Removing the lures that can currently be used would leave this page more or less empty, hence the suggestion to merge it into scams (seeing as luring is, in a way, scamming). There's already a sub-header for "Scams related to player killing", which appears to be a copy-pasta from luring.
Merge - As nominator09:31, June 11, 2018 (UTC)
Comment - why should the current lures be removed?09:40, June 14, 2018 (UTC)
- Hey Iso :D I already replied on discord, but I know discussions have to be on the wiki, so as I said, here is the answer again; we have already dissociated ourselves from another wiki (I cannot find the specific link) which was "protecting" players by sharing details of how to lure/scam under the guise of informing people how to avoid falling for such traps.
- Also, the runescape rules apply across the wiki, and, personally, I feel like sharing details which could help anyone lure or scam from a player is encouraging rule breaking. I'm sure there's a better way it could be done; but whether we remove the current luring methods or not, I still think these pages should be merged, as luring is effectively scamming, the only real difference being that with lures you have to convince a player to go to a certain area, rather than just convince them to give you their items.
- So, in short; we shouldn't be sharing details that would help rule breaking; and the pages should still be merged, because the details of both scams and lures are, at their most basic level (ie the end goal of taking another person's items via deception), identical. 21:37, June 16, 2018 (UTC)
- Linked to the comment above; RuneScape:Requests for deletion/Archive 4#Dark RuneScape Wiki the discussion that dissociated rsw from darkscape wiki, because content there was generally used by scammers. The way I see it, that's how the content on the current luring page could be used. 21:51, June 17, 2018 (UTC)
- I do not think we need to be so harsh as to remove all details about the lures. I'm not sure that luring is against the rules or if it falls into a bit of a grey area. The current RuneScape rules don't mention it specifically, and even the rule on scamming just mentions password/PIN scamming rather than in-game item scamming. Just as the information could be helpful to people looking to lure/scam, it also provides people with information that could be helpful in knowing how to avoid being lured. "Luring" is a separate concept to scamming and is a term commonly used by players so I do think that a page on the subject should exist. I think that the current information could be cut down, perhaps removing some of the details that are not relevant to avoiding the lures, but I think that removing large amounts of information is not warranted and would be detrimental to readers. 09:43, June 21, 2018 (UTC)
Oppose - An 11 year old discussion does not constitute a precedent. Helping rule breakers is one thing, but as a resource for players, we should provide information to help them avoid being lured. I think the potential benefits of the page outweigh the risks it poses. User:Cqm/Signature